Joel and that shutdown menu

by Matt 29. November 2006 09:12

Joel Spolsky had a small rant about how to shutdown Vista. And since it was Joel, it's actually become an issue. Unfortunately, I think Joel should look up the meaning of the word "disingenuous".

The crux of the argument is that you have 15 options of what to do when you leave your computer. And that's too many. Certainly sounds too many when you say it like that. Shame it's not quite so clear cut.

The Start menu has two buttons, lock and power off. Firstly, these buttons will be the most pushed. My mom will use this buttons. She won't bother with the menu, which incidentally, contains 7 different actions. It's this menu that's most controversial. I'll come back to that. Other options are the four laptop fn key combinations. Really. How many people have read their laptop manual enough to know that you can turn off, sleep, hibernate and (I'm guessing) lock using the fn key? These buttons are a terrible idea, but how much would Microsoft get slated if they didn't support them? Closing the lid and using the power button are more physical, intuitive ways of shutting down your machine - they have to be supported.

The "advanced" menu is definitely a poor way of doing advanced UI, but put simply, each outcome is stilll required. And what actually is the alternative? Joel suggests combining lock with switch user. Go on - lock Vista now. Look at the screen. Is it just me, or does that button say Switch User? He also suggests merging sleep and hibernate. Great idea. Should we tell Microsoft? Getting rid of log out is probably not going to go down well with enterprises. Restart replaced with shutdown and then power on? This one might actually have legs. But that wouldn't work on a headless server box that I controlled via remote desktop and wanted to restart.

Personally, if it weren't for the video driver power issues I've got, I'd just be closing the lid and wandering off.

Oh, and the iPod does have an on/off button - hold the play button down. It turns off. When it's turned off, I have to press the select button to turn it back on - any other button doesn't work. And that's more opaque than Vista's lock/off buttons, closing the lid or pressing the power button. I get that Joel's point was that the iPod doesn't need an off button, and generally, it doesn't. But unfortunately for Joel's argument, Apple are giving the user more, advanced choices. (And was he really comparing an operating system with an mp3 player?)

Joel, really. Disingenuous. It's a great word.

Tags:

Vista

Comments (14) -

suv review
suv review
7/20/2011 10:22:52 PM #

Fantastic task I like your type! Would really like to right here your feedback on my website! I am also seeking for someone to help you me make websites!

Reply

iphone os 4
iphone os 4
7/23/2011 7:56:27 PM #

Fantastic task I like your type! Would really like to right here your feedback on my website! I am also seeking for someone to help you me make websites!

Reply

ipad features
ipad features
7/24/2011 4:05:19 AM #

I've recently began a weblog, the data you provide on this site has helped me tremendously. Thanks for all your time & work.

Reply

Philix
Philix United States
11/21/2015 12:53:38 AM #

wonderful website.

Reply

philix
philix United States
11/22/2015 1:19:16 PM #

ace website.

Reply

Jamison Gerraro
Jamison Gerraro United States
1/15/2016 5:00:12 AM #

Congratulations on your success! You deserve it for brightening all of my work days with something to be excited about.

Reply

Chang Carbonneau
Chang Carbonneau United States
1/15/2016 6:24:03 AM #

getting laid AWSOME

Reply

Arlie Toth
Arlie Toth United States
1/15/2016 6:44:26 AM #

Congratulations, Neil! I love this site and I know I'll love the book. Christmas, birthdays, Father's Day 2010  check!

Reply

Wallace Chappelear
Wallace Chappelear United States
1/15/2016 7:19:21 AM #

Printing out an essay or paper, reading the first line and realizing there aren't any mistakes.<br />AWESOME!

Reply

Chang Carbonneau
Chang Carbonneau United States
1/15/2016 8:59:32 AM #

Congratulations, Neil! I love this site and I know I'll love the book. Christmas, birthdays, Father's Day 2010  check!

Reply

Daria Justin
Daria Justin United States
8/25/2016 3:58:16 AM #

Times are changing and so as technology. We hope to find smart home builders using the recent technologies available in the market.

Reply

Dina Schinkel
Dina Schinkel United States
1/24/2017 8:10:31 AM #

Once you hire a mobile app development company you will soon realize that you are on the track to bigger and better things - and that is what truly matters the most. This application helps you send files from your phone to your computer and vice versa--you can even send them to other phones that are connected to the same wireless network (even if they are not Android phones). And if it's wrong, they'll have start over again, not to mention if it's not mobile optimized they can't find the information the want quickly... and the pain goes on... Keeping track with your iPhone app on the store is very essential.

Reply

best white gold rings etsy coupon
best white gold rings etsy coupon United States
2/21/2017 4:42:14 AM #

Having read this I thought it was rather enlightening. I appreciate you spending some time and effort to put this informative article together. I once again find myself spending a lot of time both reading and leaving comments. But so what, it was still worth it!

Reply

patent idea
patent idea United States
5/30/2017 5:38:54 AM #

I'm extremely pleased to discover this web site. I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly fantastic read!! I definitely appreciated every bit of it and i also have you saved as a favorite to see new stuff on your website.

Reply

Add comment

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading

Rel=Me

Month List

RecentComments

Comment RSS